Hello Rodney,
The DI is the ideal critical diameter, it is a number that represents the hardenability, properly the diameter of a bar of a given steel that would get 50% martensite in its core when quenched with an ideally drastic quench. Put in other words, the DI relates how deep you can harden a material by quenching a completely austenitised section of steel. Moreover, the DI by itself does not reflect how hard (e.g. in HRC) the steel could get, but how deep you can find martensite.
What dictates the surface hardness is the carbon content on the steel, and how hardness decreases going deep into the material is a function of the chemistry of the steel (hardenability, DI) and the quench procedure (medium, temperature of quench medium, agitation, etc). So answering your question, if you have a lower DI steel, you could expect shallower cases, or lower hardness at the core.
------------------------------
Jose Mariano Flores Herrera
Heat Treat Engineer
Caterpillar
San Nicolas de los Garza
5218717957482
mariano@flores-h.com------------------------------