Chemistry, grain size, and structure matter.
The hardenability (D.I.) value of that grade could vary greatly due to small alloy additions or not. Check your two chem certs in a hardenability calculator (SAE J406 / ASTM A255). Also, the minor chems could affect how quickly you have to quench and miss the knee of the TTT.
Grain size coming to you could affect post-heat treat grain size and hardness.
Also, the mill structure coming to you matters. If it's cold rolled, it could recrystallize/nucleate grains on the way up to austenite during induction heating. If it's a very annealed, open pearlite and ferrite structure, or even spheroidized structure, it will take longer at temp or higher temp to fully austenitize before quench.
------------------------------
Greg Ward, P.E.
Metallurgist
Auburn, MI
------------------------------