Thanks Paul,
The alloy we are looking for is NOT from PERMACAST. It is just a coincident that the alloy spec has a PC in its name. The Permacast Website that colleagues on the group have visited, gives no indication that they ever manufactured any alloy. Some of the parts they make are numbered/identified with a suffix PC.
The Company that did make this alloy was known as PIAD, which does not exist anymore. The alloy is not patented, if it was, we would have found a patent. Assuming it did exist, I am sure it expired many years ago. So we are now re-inventing the wheel. Thank you for mentioning Woldman's Engineering Alloys. I will try to find and see if this helps.
Anyway, thank you for your comments and support.
Sincerely
Lalit Kumarr Pahwa
Managing Director & CEO
Pahwa MetalTech Pvt Ltd
CIN: U28113PN2014PTC158369
Chakan, Pune 410501 India
Mo: +91 98500 20000
Original Message:
Sent: 8/20/2024 7:21:00 PM
From: Paul Tibbals
Subject: RE: Copper alloy - Brass Specs
It seems like the OP's info request has been satisfied.
Maybe someone did mention in the thread that the original alloy was from Perma-Cast, I missed that. Makes sense in the designation. The current company that comes up with that name makes swimming pool hardware, so maybe the company is defunct, or the name was bought or the company changed hands or commercial focus, or the trademark was lost due to the company not defending it.
An alloy's composition can be patented, and the name can be trademarked. Patents have a finite lifetime, and the comments made suggest that it's been a long time since the alloy was called out. But the composition is much more often held as a trade secret. Though I have handbooks full of industrial but non-standardized alloys that have generic compositions listed - see Woldman's Engineering Alloys, on offer here at ASMI, for example.
One cannot use the originator's trademarked name for the alloy. But anyone competent with a metallograph and an analyzer can probably get well along to duplicating it if part of the original is at hand, and it isn't unlawful if not violating a patent. Does that give someone the expertise in the development and production equivalent to the originator? Of course not. The OP was asking for a source of the material to supply it to his customer. As I suggested the OP, and his customer, need to evaluate whether mere duplication to a "dead guy's rules" is good enough.
------------------------------
Paul Tibbals
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 08-20-2024 15:56
From: Kenneth Kubarych
Subject: Copper alloy - Brass Specs
Sorry to sound somewhat sarcastic, but there have been many well thought out responses; however, the important fact that has been clearly established is that PC-12 SB is a proprietary alloy of Perma-Cast. You will not find the composition published in the open literature and it is unlikely that an honorable professional would give it to if they were to know it. You have only three choice,1. direct your customer to Perma-Cast for them to make the part, 2. seek a license from Perma-cat to produce their alloy or 3. do the Materials Engineering to find a suitable substitute commercially available alloy that meets the customer's physical and mechanical requirements.
Ken
------------------------------
Kenneth Kubarych
Solar Turbines Inc.
Del Mar CA
(858) 204-2121
Original Message:
Sent: 07-31-2024 06:31
From: Lalit Kumar Pahwa
Subject: Copper alloy - Brass Specs
A customer has specified two copper alloys on a part drawing sent to us. The first one is 'PC-12 SB Brass' It has a tensile strength of 63 - 70 Ksi and elongation of 30-34 % in a 50 mm specimen. The electrical conductivity is 35 - 38% IACS. The second one is CDA 815 with tensile strength of 54-59 Ksi, elongation of 20-25 % on a 50 mm specimen and IACS - 70%. The only additional information I have is PILAD. I guess, this is the name of the original manufacturer which does not exist anymore.
I am unable to find a UNS number or any other standard equivalent. I will greatly appreciate if anyone can help me with finding the UNS equivalent grade or tell me that this is a variant of a std grade.
------------------------------
Lalit Kumar Pahwa
Managing Director
Pahwa MetalTech Pvt Ltd
Pune
+91 98500 20000
------------------------------